EY Y01 L15 Revenge

This week’s Questions

  1. As with all great storytelling, Japanese manga, movies and literature are infused with tales of revenge. Name one. Give us a brief outline of the story; who gets their revenge on who, and for what? If you are not Japanese, tell us about a book or movie from your country where a protagonist seeks or receives his or her revenge.
  2. Did you like this story? Why?
  3. In the news, retaliation is a common theme. This may be between politicians, companies, sports personalities (or clubs), nations or celebrity spouses. Tell me about a real world act of retaliation or revenge.
  4. Did you feel in this case that the retaliation was reasonable? Why?
  5. Tell us about a time when you or someone you know has felt the need to retaliate against a spouse, sibling, parent, friend, boss, colleague or stranger. What happened? Your story can be serious or funny.
  6. Do you feel in this case that you, or the person you know, struck a balance, or simply made the situation worse?

This week’s Responses

Sorry. You must be logged in to view this form.

Teacher’s Compositions


by Kamille Mercado

February 18, 2020

Read Now

Question 1

The most famous Filipino, and our national hero, is Jose Rizal. His two masterpieces, Noli Me Tangere and El Filibusterismo, helped spark the revolution which led to the war that kicked out the Spaniards from the Philippines. El Filibusterismo is primarily about revenge. The main character is Simoun, he is a mysterious, wealthy and extremely intelligent Filipino gentleman that came back to the Philippines after being abroad in Spain for many years. The big twist is that he is actually Chrisostomo Ibarra, believed to have been murdered by the Spaniards from the previous book, Noli Me Tangere, and he has come back to exact his revenge on the Spaniards. After slowly getting close the most powerful Spaniards in Manila, he throws a huge party in his house where he secertly planted bombs all over the place to kill all the evil Spaniards. His plan fails and he dies miserably.

Question 2

I really liked this story, because it so accurately depicted the terrible situation Filipinos were facing at the time. I think it was very important for Simoun to fail in the end. If he had succeeded, the Filipinos reading the story would have felt satisfied and maybe wouldn't become angry enough to start the revolution. Also, the Spanish goverment would probably ban the books sooner if Simoun was successful with his mission, thinking that the book was treason against Spain.

Question 3

The famous romantic poet, Lord Byron, used to love animals and had many pets. His favorite was a Newfoundland dog named Boatswain. While attending the Cambridge Trinity College, Lord Byron liked to bring his dog with him too, but the campus has a "no dogs allowed" rule. When he reviewed the rules, he discovered that it only applied to dogs, but there no rules against bringing any other type of animal. So, one day, Lord Byron brought a bear to the school and they couldn't tell him no because there no rules against it!

Question 4

I think it was funny. People come up with all sorts of silly rules and Lord Byron showed how silly the "no dogs allowed" rule was. Dogs clearly aren't as dangerous as bears, maybe they should just make rules about how to ensure bringing your pet won't cause trouble in school.

Question 5

My brother and I have never gotten along, especially when we were kids. We would get into fights a lot, as far as I remember, it's always him that's starting the fights. I never really understood what his problem with me was so you can imagine I would get really upset sometimes. There was a time when I was so angry that I really wanted to do something bad to him, which only I would know about. I dipped his toothbrush into the toilet. But, I felt really guilty aftwerwards and ended up cleaning the toothbrush as best as I could and then put it back.

Question 6

My brother and I still don't talk to each other much but we don't fight anymore. He gave me a huge amount of money as a wedding gift, and that really surprised me. So I think, even if we aren't close, we have at least stopped being enemies. I would even do him favors every now and then!

Tough Vocabulary

- English - - Japanese -
treason 外患罪, 反逆

- 0 -

comments

See/Write Comments >


by Jim Usher

July 25, 2019

Read Now

Question 1

"The Chant of Jimmie Blacksmith", first a novel by Thomas Keneally and later adapted into a film, is a powerful story of an exploited Aboriginal Australian’s revenge against an unjust and intolerant society. It is a fictionalised account of a killing spree that took place in 1900 in New South Wales. Jimmy Governor – the real-life Jimmie Blacksmith – was eventually caught and executed for the murders of nine people.

Question 2

I haven't read the book and I haven't seen the film. The fact that it is based on a true story interests me but I doubt I'll get around to reading or seeing it any time soon.

Question 3

The Internet is full of these, mostly of people getting back at cheating partners. A common one I keep seeing goes like this: "My boyfriend cheated on me so I convinced him we should get matching tattoos. He went first. I went home." There are better ones out there but this is short and to the point.

Question 4

Sure. If the revenge is clever and doesn't involve violence, I think it can be said to be justified. I think the best forms of revenge are where the recipient learns some kind of lesson. In this case, the cheating guy would have a constant reminder of what he did right there on his body. Plus he had to pay for the lesson. Well played, anonymous lady!

Question 5

I don't have a good story to tell here I'm afraid. I'm human so I'd be lying if I said I'd never had vengeful thoughts before. But all I can think of is petty stuff from when I was a kid. Name-calling, pushing someone over, that kind of thing. Nothing epic, nothing clever, nothing worthy of repeating here.

Question 6

Given my answer to Question 5, I've got nothing to add here.

Tough Vocabulary

- English - - Japanese -
adapt 適応する
exploit 悪用する
unjust 不当な
intolerant 不寛容
killing spree 殺人
recipient 受取人
vengeful すごい
epic エピック
pursue 追求する

- 2 -

comments

See/Write Comments >


by Michael Kane

July 23, 2019

Read Now

Question 1

I think that there are many comic book stories that are good examples of exacting revenge. To me the most classic has to be "Batman". The original Batman movie shows us a young Bruce Wayne(Batman) witnessing the murder of his parents after a show. He grows up very wealthy as he inherits his family fortune. He vows to come back and get revenge on the murderer, who later in the story becomes the "Joker" played by Jack Nicholson.

Question 2

Yeah. I think that it is a great story. I like how the city of Gotham is a dark and mysterious city. I like how Batman is anonymous to the public. He keeps it a secret that he is battling crime. Also, the original writer of the comic book is Bob Kane. My father shares the same name. He is also a Bob Kane.

Question 3

The Kardashians are a family that has a reality show in America. They have become rich and famous for doing basically nothing. There have been many scandals and revenges in their famous circle. There are many cases of backstabbing and cheating. I think it is more of an act to promote the reality show.

Question 4

I think that some of the retaliation was reasonable, but a lot of it was just to make the reality show exciting. If there is no fighting and revenge it's a boring show. I think the show is boring either way.

Question 5

I was at a Red Sox game in Boston with my wife about 10 years ago. Daisuke Matsuzaka was pitching and not doing so well in the third inning. I rude father with his family kept yelling rude things with derogatory words towards Japanese people. Mostly just racist things. He didn't know that a Japanese woman was sitting in front of him, but that is beside the point. I went and bought soda, beer, and a hot dog with extra ketchup and mustard. As I was making my way through the narrow aisle of seats. I purposely dumped the food and drink all over him and his wife. He thought it was an accident until I said meet my Japanese girlfriend.

Question 6

I feel like I struck a perfect balance. When he realized that it was purposeful he become so angry and left the game.

Tough Vocabulary

- English - - Japanese -
exacting まさに
derogatory 軽蔑的
aisle 通路
purposeful わいせつな

- 3 -

comments

See/Write Comments >


by Jon Hay

July 23, 2019

Read Now

Question 1

There is an old but popular revenge movie from New Zealand called "Utu". In this story a Maori warrior find his village massacred and vows revenge against the British.

Question 2

It is a good story, and it is based on real events. It was released in the early 1980s and it has a similar feel to an American Western.

Question 3

I am a fan of rugby league and there are many rivalries. There are many instances of retaliation especially between New South Wales and Queensland. Youtube has so many videos and one of my favorites is Luke Bailey and Carl Webb. Bailey runs at Webb and Webb makes an illegal tackle. Bailey then runs at Webb again and this time Webb wins the ball.

Question 4

I think it was fine as no one got seriously hurt. And the ill-feelings stayed on the field.

Question 5

I felt that I wanted revenge against my first wife. I did not get revenge as I thought I would regret my actions later.

Question 6

I feel that it remains unbalanced but there is nothing I can do. It is better to "let sleeping dogs lie".

Tough Vocabulary

- English - - Japanese -
massacre 殺戮
rivalries

- 3 -

comments

See/Write Comments >

My Composition for this Conversation

@

Not recently active